Monday, March 7, 2016

Millbank Estate: turn of the century social housing



On a site not far from where once a mill has stood on the Thames lies the area known as Millbank. Here the first modern prison in London, Millbank Penitentiary would be opened in 1816. The marshy site in Pimlico was purchased on behalf of the Crown by Jeremy Bentham to build the first example of the Panopticon he had devised. This National Penitentiary was eventually constructed after plans by William Williams, redesigned by Thomas Hardwick and built by John Harvey and his successor Robert Smirke as the site proved difficult for the erection of such a massive construction. It had separate cells for 860 prisoners and served as a holding facility for prisoners before transport to Australia. The prison was costly to run and in time it was decided to make the Model Prison Pentonville into the National Penitentiary and abandon the Millbank facility.

In 1885 the site is thus earmarked for development and demolition of the fortress-like prison complex began. The principle buildings erected in its stead, were the National Gallery of British Art, now rebranded Tate Britain (built 1893-1897) and the Royal Army Medical School (1905-1907) now in use by the Chelsea College of Art & Design. Following on from the Boundary Estate in Shoreditch the London County Council (LCC) decides to develop the site for a large-scale, inner-city housing complex for the working classes. In those days the wharfs and warehouses on the Thames lay close by, so the provision of housing for harbour workers made sense. In 1896 a street plan is approved. Construction starts in 1897 and ends in 1902. For the construction bricks from the demolished prison were used.



The octagonal outline of the prison complex can still be recognised in the street plan of this part of Pimlico. Tate Britain (1) takes pride of place on the river bank. Behind it the LCC Millbank Estate (2) and the Millbank Gardens (3). The CCAD occupies the former medical school (4).

The apartment blocks were designed by R. Minton Taylor in a style in-between the Mansion Block and Dutch-revival brick architecture. The result is a convincing ensemble of symmetrically arranged, asymmetrically detailed blocks on a plinth and with stone door surrounds. The estate comprises of 17 buildings, each named after a distinguished painter. The streets were planted with London Plane trees. Between the blocks communal gardens, laid to lawn, were included. At the centre a winged building with a school for boys and a school for girls was included in the scheme. Whilst the housing blocks were being constructed the Millbank Gardens were laid out as a public greens space for the residents. It is best described as a Public Garden in the tradition of the German People's Park. The Millbank Estate can be seen as an example of the German tradition of social housing in so-called Reform-Mietskasernen, predating the Gartenhof.

The whole complex, including the public garden, is now Grade II listed.

Thursday, March 3, 2016

Subtle Spring: Hello Hellebore



Also known as Winter rose the Hellebore belongs to the genus Helleborus within the family Ranunculaceae and isn't related to roses at all, but to buttercups and peonies. These herbaceous and often evergreen plants are (very) poisonous which is also expressed in their scientific name which translated as harmful food. The greatest concentration of species van be found in Europe, mainly in the Balkans with some species from Asia. The most commonly grown garden plants include Helleborus niger (the Christmas rose), H. lividus, H. corsicus and H. x hybridus (derived from H. orientalis). All flower early in the year, some even in the middle of winter.



H. x hybridus 'Double White', on the left, a seedling gifted to me by my mother. In some years it flowers better than in others, sadly. H x nigercors is a hybrid of the Winter rose and the Corsican Lent rose. H. lividus flowers with green cup-like flowers. This might be a hybrid with some blood of H. foetidus, a plant also known as Dungwort.

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

Retrospective: 3 years of blogging


Three years ago -to the day- I started this blog and 327 posts have been published online since. I thought it would be a nice moment to once again reflect on which posts were most popular these past few years and which were not viewed much at all, also in comparison to my first overview a year ago. So to start off the Top 10 of best viewed blog posts with on the right the ranking in 2015:

-1-       EVA-Lanxmeer - Culemborg (NL)                                Tuindorp Buiksloterham
-2-       Beringen Mijn - Campine (BE)                                     Beringen Mijn
-3-       Carl Seitz Hof - Vienna (AT)                                         EVA-Lanxmeer
-4-       Cité Jardin André Dumont - Genk (BE)                       Carl Seitz Hof
-5-       Tuindorp Buiksloterham - Amsterdam (NL)                 Cité Jardin André Dumont
-6-       Luchtbal - Antwerp (BE)                                              Tuindorp Vooruit
-7-       Mulhouse Quadrangle - Mulhouse (FR)                      Kaiserforum
-8-       Amsterdam-Zuidoost or Bijlmer (NL)                           La Cité Moderne
-9-       Tower Gardens - London (UK)                                     Amsterdam-Zuidoost
-10-     Tuindorp Vooruit - Ede (NL)                                        Gartenstadt Rüppurr

There have been a few  changes in the Top 10. In the Top 5 EVA-Lanxmeer, an ecological estate, has moved to the first position. The Garden village in Amsterdam-North Buiksloterham has dropped as a result of the rise of especially Carl Seitz Hof in Vienna and the Cité André Dumont in Genk. The highest new entry is The Antwerp suburb of Luchtbal, especially the modernist addition south of the garden village for harbour workers has proven popular. The Mulhouse Quadrangle or Carré Mulhousien and the LCC garden suburb of Tower Gardens are the other two new entries in this Top 10. Some popular post just fell short of the Top 10: e.g. La Cité Moderne in Brussels, Gartenstadt Rüppurr in Karlsruhe, the Mining Colony Zwartberg in Genk, The Kaiserforum in Vienna, The Garden village Moortebeek in Brussels, Tuindorp De Burgh in Eindhoven, Leopoldsburg in Belgium, Margarethenhöhe in Essen, the modernist pioneer village of Nagele in the Netherlands and the Origins of Dutch Gables explained.

Equally interesting as these Top 10 are the Bottom 10:

-214-*  Cités Jardins - Brussels (BE)
-210-   Suburbs Utrecht (NL), Market Towns in the Low Countries (BE-NL-LU), Lierre (BE) and Vught (NL)
-206-   Garden Squares - London
-205-   Water wolf (NL), Water Cities in the Low Countries (BE-NL-LU) and Metro-land (UK).
-202-   Model Homes - Stuttgart (DE) and Little known grids: Düsseldorf (DE)
-200-   Fortified Cities of the Low Countries (BE-NL-LU), Kielpark - Antwerp (BE) and Axial Interventions Munich (DE)  
-197-   Nordbahndorfl - Stuttgart (DE)
-196-   Albertopolis - London (UK).

There have been quite some changes in the Bottom 10. Some of these posts in the Bottom 10 are old others are recent. So there is no clear-cut reason for these changes in overall ranking. It's not the case that general posts on a certain phenomenon (e.g. Water Cities, Fortified Cities or Model Homes Exibitions) are by definition less popular that posts on a specific project or urban area. The post on Albertopolis for instance has had little views when comparable projects (Maxvorstadt, Kaiserforum and Forum Fridericianum) have many more views. This is probably a case of the better known example attracting the most attraction. This is also the case with ecological housing projects. EVA-Lanxmeer dominates whilst In Goede Aarde gets only a franction of the attention.

* I'm excluding all impressions and the first post which makes for 214 "proper posts" in total over the past three years. Also within the group of least viewed post some have exactly the same amount of views, so they have been aggregated under the same ranking.

Some of the impression have proven more popular than others. So here the top 10:


-1-       Urban nature: survivalists (2014)
-2-       Braem Pavilion (2014)
-3-       Late flowers (2013)
-4-       Middelheim Sculpture Park (2014)
-5-       Polder village Buiksloot (2014)
-6-       GLOW 2015 (2015)
-7-       Ivy, a late developer (2014)
-8-       Beautiful Bavarian Bells (2015)
-9-       Re-inventing the wheel (2015)
-10-     Urban nature: something special (2015)